Chicago Things That Only Exist in the Mind of Post-College Suburbanites
There are certain things about Chicago that apparently only exist in the minds of people who grew up in the suburbs, went away to college, and then moved into the city at 22.
These are people who have lived in Chicago for three years and somehow know more about being a Chicagoan than people who have lived here their entire lives.
They have rules.
And not just rules. Chicago rules.
The kind of rules that, if you don’t follow them, apparently the city will revoke your Chicago card.
Here are a few.
Cubs vs. White Sox
According to the people who have recently moved to the city, Chicago is divided into two warring tribes: Cubs fans on the North Side and White Sox fans on the South Side.
You must pick one.
You cannot possibly root for both.
This is nonsense.
Plenty of Chicagoans root for both teams.
Because here’s the thing: we root for Chicago.
Sure, if the Cubs and White Sox are playing each other, you might have a preference. And yes, we might make fun of North Siders or South Siders depending on where we live and who we’re talking to.
That’s part of the fun.
But when it comes down to it, they’re both Chicago teams.
When one of them is playing somebody from St. Louis, Milwaukee, Detroit, New York or wherever, I’m not suddenly going to pretend they’re the enemy because I have a preferred baseball team.
That’s not how this works.
The idea that Chicagoans are required to hate one of our own teams is something I suspect was invented by somebody who discovered Wrigleyville after graduation and thought neighborhood boundaries were a personality.
Ketchup on a hot dog
This one drives me crazy.
Yes, you can put ketchup on a hot dog in Chicago.
You just don’t put ketchup on a Chicago dog.
Those are two different things.
A Chicago dog is a specific hot dog. It comes with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, sport peppers, celery salt, a pickle and whatever other argument people want to have about the proper arrangement of vegetables.
There is already tomato on it.
Putting ketchup on it would be redundant.
It’s like putting pineapple on a Hawaiian pizza and then announcing that pineapple is forbidden on pizza.
No.
You can put ketchup on a regular hot dog.
You can put mustard on it.
You can put sauerkraut on it.
You can put whatever the hell you want on it.
The only people who seem genuinely offended by this are the gatekeepers.
You know the type.
They’ve lived in Logan Square for fourteen months and now they’re prepared to lecture you about the proper application of condiments.
Relax.
Nobody is coming to take away your Chicago passport because you ordered ketchup.
Malört
And then there’s Malört.
Malört is supposedly this essential part of the Chicago experience.
Except it isn’t.
It wasn’t.
And it certainly wasn’t when I was growing up.
Somehow this stuff has gone from obscure, terrible-tasting liquor to The Official Beverage of Authentic Chicago™.
It isn’t.
It’s a manufactured Chicago tradition that seems to have become popular because people who moved here wanted something they could use to demonstrate that they were really Chicago now.
“Yeah, I’m from Naperville, but I’ve lived in Chicago for six years and I drink Malört.”
Congratulations.
I have bad news for you.
Drinking something that tastes like somebody distilled a tire fire doesn’t make you more Chicago.
And let’s be honest about what happens.
Some bartender gives a group of twenty-something transplants a round of Malört.
Everyone takes a shot.
Everyone makes the same horrible face.
Everyone laughs.
Someone takes a picture.
And suddenly it’s a Chicago tradition.
No.
That’s not a tradition.
That’s a bar trick.
Malört isn’t some sacred Chicago inheritance passed down from generation to generation.
It’s something that became fashionable because people started telling other people that it was fashionable.
You don’t have to drink Malört to be a Chicagoan.
You don’t have to hate the Cubs if you’re a Sox fan.
You don’t have to hate the Sox if you’re a Cubs fan.
And you can put ketchup on your damn hot dog.
You just can’t put it on a Chicago dog and then call it a Chicago dog.
There.
Now you can go back to Naperville.